| Year | Winner | Runner-Up |
| 2024 | David Jack | Shahid Razaq |
| 2023 | Scott Dunbar | Vince Kenny |
| 2022 | David Jack | Marc Fleming |
| 2020 | Scott Coventry | Gary McLeish |
| 2019 | Marc Fleming | Bryan Cumming |
| 2018 | Marc Fleming | David Jack |
| 2017 | Colin Brown | Scott Coventry |
| 2016 | Scott Dunbar | David Jack |
| 2015 | David Jack | Ryan Tenbruck |
| 2014 | Marc Fleming | David Jack |
| 2013 | Marc Fleming | David Jack |
| 2012 | Jimmy Pollock | Iain Soutar |
| 2011 | Ryan Fleming | Josh Brannan |
| 2010 | Jimmy Pollock | Garry Mitchell |
| 2009 | Marc Fleming | Brian Harewood |
| 2008 | Jimmy Pollock | Iain Soutar |
